Climate Issues by Rich Seager

siouxsiewiles

Subtitle: Better chance of finding god

In her PhD 'defense' on Twitter, Siouxsie Wiles mentioned that she'd received her PhD from Edinburgh Napier University. There is a chance that this is true, but if so it's likely that she's received a PhD via this method (which was one of my OIA questions);

Because not only has Siouxsie Wiles not provided a thesis as evidence that she has a PhD but once again there's no thesis in a search engine that specializes in these sort of searches. This time on the Edinburgh Napier University website, a search from 1997 to 2005 in alphabetical order. It jumps from David Ian White in 2002 to Simon Wilkinson in 2001. There is nobody by the surname of Wiles (a surname that Siouxsie has never stopped using and one that she was definitely using around this period).

For those who are unaware of what a PhD normally entails it's a guided research project over several years supervised by someone at the University you're doing your PhD at who has the qualifications necessary to act as your supervisor (i.e. they have a relevant PhD with research and teaching in that area or jurisdiction). This then results in a substantial (i.e. more or less a book) output which is known as a thesis. At the end of your PhD you defend this thesis in front of a panel (2+) of examiners/academics. And so you become a Doctor (PhD) but not very often a Medical Doctor (MD) as the MD is a separate degree.

20200915 Update: Auckland University has stated in a reply to my OIA that Siouxsie Wiles received her PhD from Edinburgh Napier University in the normal way (not via one of Edinburgh Napier's expedited routes). They have also stated who her supervisors were. But they have also stated that “As noted in the University's Calendar, which is publicly available, Associate Professor Wiles' PhD was awarded by Edinburgh Napier University.” This is not the case, the only reference on Siouxsie Wiles University pages is to the “centre for Ecology and Hydrology in Oxford” which is not part of Oxford University.

But disregarding what seems to be an attempt to associate herself with Oxford rather than Edinburgh Napier University her thesis should be publicly available, but I have yet to find it via a general search, via Edinburgh Napier University or via https://ethos.bl.uk/Home.do

There are references to her as a Dr in several places in the 2000s while she was in the UK so these references do not support the idea that she does not have a PhD.

But I think the lack of a thesis in those databases, or for that matter online, or for that matter offered up recently when Siouxsie Wiles reacted to my OIA request is very odd. Someone's thesis is normally much easier to find than this.

#badscience #science #politics #actualscientists #siouxsiewiles @siouxsiew #siouxsiew #fyi #oia #phd

Enter your email to subscribe to updates.

Subtitle: Or is it a DFool?

Siouxsie Wiles, all over New Zealand news media over the last 6 months or more for her supposed expertise on COVID-19, claims to have a Ph.D and at least once she's claimed that it is from Oxford, the implication of course being that it's from Oxford University. Doctorates from Oxford University are normally called a DPhil rather than Ph.D, or PHD as referred to on at least one of Siouxsie's copious social media or online biography pages. But there's no evidence of such a doctorate, whatever it is called, for example this database has no record of it;

https://ethos.bl.uk/Home.do

And Siouxsie's Wikipedia page referenced this paper as her Ph.D thesis before I challenged it a few months ago (the Wikipedia link is to an archived version of her page).

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167701203002033

That paper is only 10 pages long, it has three co-authors which would be very unusual for a thesis and nowhere other than Wikipedia do I see it mentioned as a thesis. The chances of that paper being her thesis are close to zero.

I've filed an OIA at Auckland University to proffer up proof that Siouxsie Wiles has what she claims to have. What prompted that?

This bit of anti-science (and good on you Sammy, we need more of you – Keywords: woman, PhD);

And advisor rather than supervisor? I know that there might be some terminology differences between countries but I thought the term was 'supervisor'. And yes you are supposed to notice the pink hair, it's better than concentrating on her 'expertise' in whatever field the NZ newsmedia has asked her to comment on today. Anyway...

20200909 Update: Siouxsie has had a go at defending her Ph.D on Twitter. That's novel. There is still no thesis offered in evidence though. But at least we've cleared up that it's not an Oxbridge PhD. And bonus, we have extras! Bill Gates eh? And not to miss the little dash of libel. I might take it more seriously but ...

#badscience #science #politics #feminism #actualfeminists #actualscientists #transgender #siouxsiewiles @siouxsiew #siouxsiew #fyi #oia #phd

Enter your email to subscribe to updates.